It would be nice to know what firmware you are running in both scanners. Many, though by no means everyone, have found that the newest firmware does perform better on P25 decode - though it should be noted that some folks have actually found it worse.
You can find some discussion about thresholds, end codes and more in the RR Wiki DMA FAQ;
http://wiki.radioreference.com/index.php/Uniden_DMA_FAQRead the article on adjusting the P25 decode level, and the ones that follow it (all links are in blue)
As noted earlier, there's a lot of factors that can affect P25 decoding. One of the worst - and one that we really can't do anything about - has to do with simulcast distortion. What system(s) are you listening to? Be as specific as you can - go to the RR Database and supply the URLs.
73 Mike